What a good board actually does

This week is Trustees' Week, the annual moment to recognise the nearly one million people across the UK who give their time to sit on charity boards. Most of them are unpaid. Plenty of them are doing it on top of a full-time job. And a good number of them, if you asked, couldn't tell you with any confidence whether their board is doing a good job.
So this is for them, and for the founders and managers who work alongside them. If you run a CIC, your directors aren't trustees in the legal sense, but the job is much the same, and everything here applies to you too.
What a good board does
A good board keeps the purpose in the room. Day to day, everyone is busy delivering, chasing funding and putting out fires. The board is the one place where someone should regularly ask: is all this activity still serving the reason we exist?
A good board asks the awkward questions. Not to catch anyone out, but because somebody has to. Can we afford this? What happens if that contract isn't renewed? Are we sure this is what our community actually wants? If nobody on your board ever asks a question that makes the room go a bit quiet, it isn't doing its job.
A good board shares the weight. One of the loneliest positions in the sector is the founder or chief officer carrying every decision on their own. A board that genuinely shares responsibility, for the money, for the risks, for the hard calls, makes the whole organisation more resilient.
A good board brings what the staff team doesn't have. Finance, legal, HR, marketing, lived experience, local connections. The best boards are deliberately built to fill gaps, rather than assembled from whoever happened to be available.
And a good board looks ahead. Operational detail belongs with the people running things. The board's time is best spent on where the organisation needs to be in three years, and what could knock it off course.
I've recently been asked to deliver some trustee training for a couple of clients, helping new trustees understand what they should (and more importantly, shouldn't be doing). It has given me a chance to reflect on some of the boards I have worked with before. One in particular stands out as being exceptionally strong. CXK is a large Kent charity and throughout the 10 years I have known the organisation the trustees have always been a high calibre, empathetic, insightful, supportive and helpfully challenging group. The board culture is strong and dynamic, which is why new trustees have a secure environment to walk into and clear guidance on what is expected of them. I see they're recruiting new trustees now. I bet they get someone good!
Signs your board might need some attention
• Meetings are mostly reports being read aloud, with little time left for discussion
• Only one person in the room really understands the finances
• The same people have been around the table for many years, with no plan for who comes next
• The board hears about problems after everyone else
• Decisions are effectively made before the meeting, and the board just signs them off
None of these make you a bad organisation. They're very common, especially in small charities and social enterprises where everyone is stretched. But each one is worth fixing.
Five things to do before your next meeting
1. Add one question to the agenda: "What aren't we talking about?" Give it ten minutes and see what comes up.
2. Do a one-page skills check. List the skills you need, tick off the ones you have, and you'll see exactly who to recruit next.
3. Look at the money together. Ask your treasurer or finance lead to walk the whole board through the accounts in plain English, and keep going until everyone can explain them back.
4. Talk about succession. Who chairs next? Who takes over from your longest-serving trustee? These conversations are much easier when nobody is about to leave.
5. Read the Charity Governance Code. It was refreshed during Trustees' Week last year, the biggest revision in eight years, and the new version is built around helping boards reflect on how they actually behave rather than ticking off processes. It's written for charities, but any social enterprise board will find it useful.
Thank you
If you're a trustee or a director of a social purpose organisation, thank you. It's often thankless work, done in the evenings, and it matters far more than most people realise.
If your board would benefit from a fresh pair of eyes, whether that's a governance review, help recruiting new trustees, or simply a conversation about how things are working, book a free 45-minute advice session with me. It's a good place to start.
Want more like this? Sign up to our monthly newsletter, Enterprising Times, at the foot of this page.




Comments